Investor State Dispute Settlement is being blamed for countries' slowness to shift regulatory structures against the continued development of fossil fuels' extraction - the fossil fuels sector has been a voracuus user of ISDS and has profited handsomely from settlements....
So, what is ISDS?
A couple of years ago I wrote this quick guides @NWBylines which you may find helps you understand what is going on.
Why fear of billion-dollar lawsuits stops countries phasing out fossil fuels
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/mar/06/isds-fear-of-billion-dollar-lawsuits-stops-countries-phasing-out-fossil-fuels-aoe
#isds #ISDSs
Why fear of billion-dollar lawsuits stops countries phasing out fossil fuels
"A 2023 UN report by David Boyd, the special rapporteur on human rights and the environment, found Denmark, New Zealand and France had limited their climate policies because of the threat of #ISDS. The report stated that this threat has become a “major obstacle” for countries addressing the #climate crisis."
Why fear of billion-dollar lawsuits stops countries phasing out fossil fuels - https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/mar/06/isds-fear-of-billion-dollar-lawsuits-stops-countries-phasing-out-fossil-fuels-aoe #ISDS is pure corporate evil; some of us were warning about it in 2013...
These are the kind of stories highlighting the dangers of #isds when letting foreign investors in with their demands of profit. Particularly around big oil, mining, tobacco, etc.
This is also why we must resist new mining at the Coromandel in Aotearoa or sea bed mining off the west coast. Even if it means some lost potential jobs. But with the profits going overseas, that but will never make up for the mess left behind when they leave.
Fearing toxic waste, Greenland ended uranium mining. Now, they could be forced to restart - or pay $11bn
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/mar/05/greenland-mining-energy-transition-minerals-environmental-laws-uranium-rare-earth-toxic-waste-investor-state-dispute-settlement-isds-aoe
#ISDS #mining #environment
'When it took power, the new government kept its campaign promise, passing legislation to ban uranium mining. While not primarily a uranium mine, the Kvanefjeld project would require unearthing the radioactive substance to extract its rare earth oxides, putting it in violation of the law.
Many Greenlanders celebrated the vote as a victory for health and the environment. But three years later, the company is suing Greenland for stopping its plans, demanding the right to exploit the deposit or receive compensation of up to $11.5bn: nearly 10 times the country’s 8.5bn krone (£950m) annual budget.
Kvanefjeld’s operator, Energy Transition Minerals (ETM), the Australian-listed company formerly known as Greenland Minerals, argues that the decision to ban mining amounts to expropriation by Greenland’s government and any environmental concerns would be addressed with the “best environmental practice, where this was technically, practically and financially possible”.
It has taken the case to arbitration through the investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS), a once-obscure provision in trade agreements that has become a lucrative area of international law, alongside cases in Greenland and Denmark.'
Fearing toxic waste, #Greenland ended #uranium mining. Now, they could be forced to restart - or pay $11bn - https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/mar/05/greenland-mining-energy-transition-minerals-environmental-laws-uranium-rare-earth-toxic-waste-investor-state-dispute-settlement-isds-aoe the evil #ISDS of course; we did warn them...
our 17th TDM LinkedIn newsletter highlights our Young-OGEMID Seminar on Young- #Illegality and #Corruption in #ISDS. In this Young-OGEMID Symposium, our panelists will delve into Illegality and Corruption in ISDS, examining the challenges posed by these critical issues, and discussing potential developments that could strengthen justice in the realm of international investment law moving forward. Co-moderators: Wooseok Shin and Dr Stanislava Nedeva.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/young-ogemid-symposium-illegalitycorruption-isds-february-zot5e/
I Tribunali delle imprese e il record di cause contro i Paesi dell’America Latina https://altreconomia.it/i-tribunali-delle-imprese-e-il-record-di-cause-contro-i-paesi-dellamerica-latina/ #Investorsstatedisputesettlements #corsaallaricercadimaterieprime #arbitratointernazionale #transnationalinstitute #combustibilifossili #giustiziaparallela #Approfondimento #americalatina #metallirari #minerali #arbitri #giudici #litio #ISDS
Still, it’ll be nice to get back to being a Rule-Taker.
In this case Investor-State Dispute Settlement #ISDS is a particularly special new rule.
Is your company losing money because of pesky environmental measures? That’s OK, just sue the offending government and their taxpayers will compensate you.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investor%E2%80%93state_dispute_settlement
Dus dat kloterige Energie Handvest Verdrag, waar de Nederlandse regering onder aanvoering van wijlen Ruud Lubbers (CDA) zich indertijd hard voor heeft gemaakt, biedt #ExxonMobil nu de mogelijkheid om de Nederlandse staat een flinke poot uit te draaien vanwege het sluiten van het Groninger gasveld.
https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2024/10/10/exxonmobil-opnieuw-arbitragezaak-tegen-nederlandse-staat-wegens-financiele-afwikkeling-sluiting-groningse-gasvelden-a4868954
#ISDS #Groningen #aardgas #RuudLubbers
Q. is #water denationalisation is on the cards how might things fair for the UK Govt. if the firms start proceedings under investment treaty protections (via #ISDS)?
For a quick guide see this I wrote for @NWBylines a while ago
2/2
Some of the things that have appeared in my posts over the last month or so have appeared in extended form @NWBylines - so if you interested in my reflections on these:
#ISDS - Investor State Dispute Settlement
#Oligopolies in the UK
#SeafarerAbandonment & the labour market
#supplychains, or
the economic aspects of #LongCovid,
you can find the articles here:
https://northwestbylines.co.uk/author/chrismay/
My latest for @NWBylines looks at Investor State Dispute Settlement (which is part of the Comprehensive & Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership) that the UK has just joined... #ISDS is not an uncommon element of #internationaltrade agreements (despite the EU cooling on them recently).
I conclude that ISDS 'is a window on how states have either facilitated, or been forced to facilitate, an expansion of the rights of #corporations'.
#democracy
#capitalism
https://northwestbylines.co.uk/business/trade/investor-state-dispute-settlement-the-rule-of-law-or-instrument-of-corporate-power/
My latest for @NWBylines looks at Investor State Dispute Settlement (which is part of the Comprehensive & Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership) that the UK has just joined... #ISDS is not an uncommon element of #internationaltrade agreements (despite the EU cooling on them recently).
I conclude that ISDS 'is a window on how states have either facilitated, or been forced to facilitate, an expansion of the rights of #corporations'.